Professional Tenant Screening and Best Practices

Corby Goade • February 10, 2023

It's official. You've just invested in your first rental property. You're thrilled about your new investment, until the dread of the unknown creeps into your brain. One major question hovers in your mind: who will be living in your investment? How do you ensure the tenant living there will be responsible, qualified, and on top of payments?

If this sounds like you, don't panic. Tenant screening is actually easier than you might think, for one simple reason. You don't choose a tenant. Your tenant qualifies for your rental, or doesn't. This both lifts the pressure from you feeling like you have to choose the right person, and protects you from any sort of Fair Housing violation, allowing you to make objective decisions (your applicant's credit score is too low) as opposed to subjective decisions (you didn't get a good feeling about the applicant). The fact of the matter is that simple screening and guidelines will make your life easier and dramatically reduce chances of discrimination claims against you. 


So, how does professional tenant screening actually work? Your property manager will have basic criteria that every applicant must meet, such as income requirements, credit score, criminal history, etc. They make sure none of these are related to any protected classes, and make sure they screen each tenant the same way every time. The criteria will be published in the rental ad, so prospective tenants know what to expect right away. 



As you create your screening criteria, you should have two goals in mind: remain in compliance with Fair Housing requirements, and create a list that will best assist you in finding an applicant that will pay rent reliably, follow lease terms and rules, and treat the property with extreme respect. Some ethical, objective application requirements: 

  • Verification of income and employment (demonstration of ability to pay bills on time)
  • Review a credit report 
  • Follow-up with previous landlords
  • Ask for references 
  • Review criminal history 
  • Review public records
  • Review history of lease violations or history of evictions 
  • Consider pets 


The last thing to keep in mind? The first person to pass your tenant screening qualifications is offered the property. This makes it easier on you, and again, helps you avoid sticky situations. Give the prospective tenants a deadline to pay their security deposit or other financial terms as specified in your lease. If the deadline passes, move on to the next application. Remember to document everything, and keep all your communications  in writing. You never know when you might need to prove that you are operating within the boundaries of fair housing. 


Does this still seem like a lot to handle on your own? BoiseTurnKey has specific tenant screening criteria, and we'd walk you through setting up applications and rental agreements. We value protecting our clients and providing quality housing for all, and above all, we want your process to be seamless and stress-free. 


Reach out to us here with any questions or to set up a meeting with one of our agents!


By Corby Goade April 11, 2025
Most New Investors Agonize Over Timing a Purchase....Should They??
By Taylor Witmer April 8, 2025
Churn might be the best metric to monitor unnessary vacancy costs.
By Tracy Ross April 3, 2025
Spring time in Boise is the BEST time! Of course, the best way to spend spring afternoons is on the course...
By Corby Goade April 1, 2025
Especially for investors- agents can be a valuable partner
April 10, 2024
Springtime in Boise, Idaho, brings a burst of life and color after the winter chill. With its mild temperatures and beautiful landscapes, there are plenty of activities to enjoy during this vibrant season. Here are the five best things to do in Boise, Idaho, during the spring:
April 10, 2024
Itching to get away? Ready for an pre-summer, much needed vacation? We have a solution: go on a day-trip staycation to feel like a tourist in your hometown. Many of our clients, friends, and neighbors have recently moved to the great city of Boise, Idaho. However, when we move cross country (and during a pandemic!) it's easy to miss some of Boise's best spots. Here's how we would plan the day, if we were you.
April 10, 2024
Are you considering dipping your toes into the world of real estate investing? Whether you're eyeing residential properties for rental income or looking to flip houses for profit, understanding the role of credit scores is paramount. At Boise Turnkey, we believe that arming yourself with knowledge about credit scores can be a game-changer in your real estate investment journey. So, let's dive in and explore everything you need to know about credit scores in real estate investing.
April 10, 2024
Finishing an unfinished basement can significantly increase the usable space in your home and add value to your property! Here's a step-by-step guide on how to finish an unfinished basement:
December 6, 2023
Are you a savvy real estate investor looking to level up your game and rapidly grow your rental property portfolio? If so, the BRRRR method might just be the key to unlocking your next level of success. BRRRR, which stands for Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, and Repeat, is a powerful strategy that allows investors to recycle their capital and build a substantial real estate empire. In this blog post, we'll explore how you can use the BRRRR method to go from owning one rental property to an impressive portfolio of 10.
November 10, 2023
The Treasure Valley goes all out for Christmas. From ice skating, to decorations, to simply enjoying the snow and the cozy time together with our families, we at Boise Turnkey wait all year long for the joy that the holiday season brings in Boise. For this month's blog, here's our top 10 best things to do to celebrate the holidays in Boise! Whether you're new to Boise, thinking about moving to the valley, or are just looking for something new to do this year, this blog is for you!
More Posts